3-4 Point High Approach Attach-Drawback Joseki
Return to parent joseki article: 3-4 Point High Approach, Inside Contact, Hane
The 3-4 point high approach, attach-drawback joseki (Tsuke-Hiki) is one of the most popular 3-4 point joseki, and it one of the first joseki learned by beginners. Drawing back (hiki) is solid shape and secures the corner territory for Black. Meanwhile, White has a cutting point should be defended.
Typically, White will defend the cutting point with either (A) solid connection or (B) hanging connection. In rare instances, it is also possible for White to utilize (C) a sabaki strategy (light play) to move into the center. Professionals will also sometimes (D) tenuki to play a probe prior to choosing which connection, but this is an advanced tactic with its own risks.
|Table of contents|
Moves are listed by frequency in professional games, which is sensitive to whole-board position. Bolded moves are commonly considered joseki.
- a, 3-4 Point High Approach, Attach-Drawback, Solid Connection - (joseki) (beginner) (common) (AI favorite)
- b, 3-4 Point High Approach, Attach-Drawback, Hanging Connection - (joseki) (beginner) (common)
- c, 3-4 Point High Approach, Attach-Drawback, Tenuki - (joseki) (advanced)
- d, 3-4 Point high Approach, Attach-Drawback, Large Knight Jump - (joseki) (situational) (advanced)
- e, 3-4 Point high Approach, Attach-Drawback, Small Knight Jump - (situational) (advanced)
- z, 3-4 Point high Approach, Attach-Drawback, Stand - (mistake)
- Protecting White's cutting point with either a solid connection or tiger's mouth is usually recommended. Both of these joseki are similar and will typically end with Black making an extension on the left side while White takes a three-space extension on the top.
- The solid connection is usually the stronger move, and it is slightly preferred by AI programs (~90% policy) and current professionals (c. 2020) unless there is a good reason to play the hanging connection. The solid connection makes tenuki less favorable for Black, as White has a strong follow-up on the corner.
- The hanging connection is an alternative move that was historically as common as the solid connection. The hanging connection allows White to extend one space further on the top side, which can be good if there is something interesting on the top right side of the board. However, the hanging connection has certain weaknesses, and it is possible for Black to invade and create a heavy ko inside White's position. Furthermore, it places less pressure on Black's corner, so Black can choose to tenuki. For this reason, professionals have largely stopped playing the tiger's mouth as often after the AI revolution. However, it is still a perfectly good move, and it often receives an AI score that is just as favorable as the solid connection.
See main article: 3-4 point, high approach, inside contact, tenuki variation
Tenuki is played around 13% of the time, either as a probe or to take another large point. It is surprisingly common in professional play, although it should be considered an advanced tactic that is extremely difficult for amateurs to judge.
Historically, tenuki was considered playable during the opening because cutting with is gote, and Black can get a second move elsewhere on the board. This was considered an even result, and often times professionals would not cut immediately at out fear of taking gote.
However, strong AI programs have a different opinion, and cutting at is considered slightly better for White even if it is gote. For this reason, probing during the attach-drawback joseki has dropped in popularity in recent years, since strong AI programs will usually recommend immediately cutting at .
However, the valuation of this board position is subtle, and in many circumstances there is less than one point difference in winning rate. For this reason, these tenuki variations can still be considered "even" games, and some professionals continue to tenuki even in the AI era.
Large Knight Jump
Small Knight Jump
- The Large Knight Jump is a historic joseki that largely disappeared after the AI revolution. It was a move characteristic of the cosmic style and places emphasis on central influence and building a moyo. It also demonstrates sabaki (light play), in the sense that it baits Black to cut at a. However, this is generally considered a mistake, as this would give White extremely good thickness. Strong AI programs typically do not consider this to be a good move.
- The Small Knight Jump is a situational move that is primarily played when Black has a position on the top side that would block White's natural extension. It can be considered a reduction strategy that emphasizes sabaki (light play). As before, it is bad for Black to cut at a regardless of who has the ladder, as this would help White make shape.
Prior to the AI revolution, the main consideration for choosing between the solid and hanging connection was the spacing of the stone. White would play the the hanging connection whenever they wanted to extend one space further.
Isn't a further extension always better and more efficient? Actually, this is often not the case, and farther extensions typically come with more weaknesses. On an empty board, it is usually better to play the solid connection since it is stronger and more resilient. However, the considerations can change depending on the situation in the upper left corner.
The one-space counter-approach is typically a key point for both the solid connection and hanging connection joseki, since the stone activates aji () inside of White's base. Usually, Black will want to play a one-space counter-approach at some point in the opening (but not necessarily immediately).
If we compare the two main variations of the attach-drawback joseki and examine the board when Black approaches with , which one do you prefer as White? In the second diagram, Black is able to get a three-space extension from their corner enclosure, which is fairly comfortable spacing. In contrast, Black is only able to get a two-space extension with when White plays the hanging connection, which feels a little cramped. (See: Extending from an enclosure)
Most professionals felt that White is better in the first diagram, and historically the hanging connection was played more often than the solid connection (~61% vs ~14% frequency) in this particular board position.
However, the AI revolution has changed the perspective of many professionals. The hanging connection is not played as often nowadays because Black can tenuki after the tiger mouth at . White cannot be completely sure that that Black will play the extension at , which makes it difficult for White to predict the outcome of this fuseki.
In contrast, Black is less likely to tenuki when White plays the solid connection, so the solid connection is preferred by current professionals.
See main article: Probing during the attach and draw back joseki
In the late 21st century and up until the AI revolution, probing during the attach-drawback joseki was stylish. White would often tenuki after to approach the top-right corner, and once Black responded, White would decide whether to play the solid connection or hanging connection.
If Black responded with the knight's move at , White would opt to play the hanging connection with the extension at . This was considered good for White because would be better placed at b, and its current positioning is too far away to activate aji inside of White's position.
There are many different kinds of probes, but this illustrates the general principle of this popular strategy.
Professionals have largely stopped playing the tenuki/probe after the AI revolution because strong AI programs usually think that Black should cut immediately with at a instead of responding to White's tenuki.
Black often chooses to play for the center when the side is blocked by hostile stones. In this situation, the approach functions as a reduction and Black seeks to escape as quickly as possible.
Kim Sujun vs. Yamada Kimio (2010) illustrates this concept, and we can see that that the upper right quadrant of the board is White's sphere of influence. White has a large wall in the area that threatens to enclose anything that attempts to invade, and it blocks Black's natural extension. Black plays the small knight jump (), seeking to escape.
Black's two stones () are light and Black is willing to sacrifice them. In fact, the ladder at a works for White. However, cutting at a is a bad move because Black will be able to use many forcing moves to make shape (sabaki). Instead, White chases Black's weak group with and , hoping to enclose Black on a large scale.
After some forcing exchanges, Black manages to make shape for their group and escapes from the gauntlet. Meanwhile, White's moyo is destroyed and Black is happy to have carried out a successful reduction.
Historically, the large knight jump was often played by professionals in the opening when they wished to play a moyo-centric game. Often, it would even be played on an empty board on the first corner approach, which speaks to the popularity of Takemiya Masaki's style among many other professionals who attempted to imitate him.
Naturally, Strong AI programs typically do not give this a good score, as moves in the center of the board have low value (see Corners, then sides, then center). It is difficult for Black to make territory in the center of the board, and it can be challenging to pull off this strategy.
We can see that Black has accumulated a large number of stones towards the center of the board. Although it doesn't look like much of a moyo at first, Black plays to move quickly to the center. After several exchanges, appears to create a fairly intimidating moyo in the center of board, and White would definitely lose if they are unable to invade that space.
As before, cutting at a is a terrible move. While it is possible for White to capture one stone, Black will gain very thick influence on the outside, which will contribute even more to Black's whole-board strategy. When Black is playing a large moyo strategy like this, White must seek much larger moves or else they will lose.
To a beginner, Black's moyo may look scary, but strong players and AI programs generally have an easy time invading these frameworks. For this reason, the cosmic style has largely disappeared in recent years. Despite this, moyo-oriented strategies like the sanrensei fuseki are still highly effective at the amateur level of play.
is a very interesting move that was well-regarded by professionals until recently.
Perhaps you might be able to find a good situation to experiment and use it?
-  Frequency statistics were obtained from Waltheri's Go Pattern Search using the full database restrained to a local search (accessed September 2021).
-  AI preferences were examined using Katago (v1.8.0 30 blocks) with at least five thousand playouts in a wide variety of board positions. AI preferences can vary wildly based on the software version, optimization parameters, and computer hardware, so these recommendations are likely to change in the future.