BQM 515

Maybe this?  

The --- sequence is supposedly an old joseki (see 4-4 3-3 enclosure), with the next moves being at a and at b. Here, I would argue that is bad when is already played. So, tries to punish the "mistake" since the White group isn't settled yet, and White has to end up making a base in gote with .

Problem: is a bit conservative relative to the old joseki, and playing one line below at c can be considered. (Then again, one could argue that Black is trying to stay light with the attacking move, as playing at c might invite a cap with around d.)

Uberdude: Trying to show the Catenaccio joseki is poor by tewari analysis comparison with another old joseki (the 3-3 answer to the approach) that is usually considered bad as the fair result reference frame is illogical. Indeed I think this whole exercise is likely to be fruitless and would be surprised if anyone finds an answer that is not logically flawed and contains silly moves as the "normal" moves for tewari. One should just observe white 8 is on the 2nd line which is low so black 3 for white 8 is a slightly good exchange for black in the opening. As Charles says on Catenaccio Joseki this joseki is neither extinct nor superseded. It is still played occasionally these days when white wants to settle quickly in that area and prevent black getting a strong outside due to global considerations: the more common and locally better result from a territory point of view is to take the corner, often by first making a double kakari, but then black gets a wall facing his pincer stone which may have lots of potential in the side/centre.

a variation  

This is somewhat similar to MrTenuki's variation, moves 1-5 are joseki, is one point too low, usually at a. But then looks a little strange, and seems very natural, splitting from the main group. is probably a bad move, but is good here?

Tapir's try  

tapir: It is in a way a puzzle. But I don't know the solution either. I just try to strengthen my positional judgement in general that is why i keep adding tewari examples every now and then as opposed to just take for granted expertise given.

I would say - is joseki. deviates. (But there may be reasons sometime if white is particularly strong in lower left.) seems like a reasonable pincer/invasion... but especially in cases where is reasonable, would not White want to play at a or an counterpincer?