Forum for 4-5 point 4-3 approach keima, contact at 3-5
Punishing a 4-5 Joseki overplay [#3146]
psygo: Punishing a 4-5 Joseki overplay
(2015-05-13 15:10) [#10520]
![[Diagram]](diagrams/50/8de1ce46a20da1b1afe25e754f8f49ed.png)
OscarBear: Re: Punishing a 4-5 Joseki overplay
(2015-05-13 15:10) [#10521]
This is the 4th time you've asked exactly the same question, so I have to guess that the question is very important. What about this response? Is it okay as a punishment?
![[Diagram]](diagrams/7/ed9a560eb6fd3bf899687c7b06b00813.png)
tapir: Re: Punishing a 4-5 Joseki overplay
(2015-05-13 15:35) [#10522]
I allowed myself to format the diagrams in your posts (librarian special ability) and remove the multiple instances. One additional single-line answer was "depends on the whole board".
The whole mindset insisting on "punish overplay" is wrong in my opinion.
![[Diagram]](diagrams/45/d73d3cad1b6b65dcad0d39b0c103a4cc.png)
OscarBear: why not use josekipedia?
(2015-05-13 15:25) [#10523]
Later, I looked up the relevant line in josekipedia to find an answer to this question. The lines showed there didn't indicate any severe punishment, just a better for ... position. If there is a question about 1 of these lines, maybe psygo could ask a follow up question.
![[Welcome to Sensei's Library!]](images/stone-hello.png "Sensei's Library")