Forum for Page of the month
In A Korean Baduk School [#256]
New reply
DrStraw:
In A Korean Baduk School
(2006-01-13 03:22) [#872]
- ++++/-
- I like this page. It is very interesting. It was not created this month, though. I think that "edit wars" (big term for a minor nuisance) are a bad excuse for not playing fair. This page (Page of the month) has done nicely without need for spelled out rules for it until this spoiling nomination. mAsterdam
- The problem linking the edit wars to the page in question is that it is certainly possible to view it as some kind of advertising for a certain president of a certain go federation. If you don't think so, maybe have another look at the bottom of the page. dnerra
167.127.107.11:
Re: In A Korean Baduk School
(2006-01-13 12:14) [#887]
I don't see how this page can be included for this month since it was created last year. Surely it should be removed from the vote?
MAsterdam:
Re: In A Korean Baduk School
(2006-01-13 20:01) [#892]
We could move it to page of the month september 2005.
Any objections from + voters? (I would withdraw my -).
Unkx80:
Re: In A Korean Baduk School
(2006-01-13 20:28) [#896]
No objections from me...
MAsterdam:
Re: In A Korean Baduk School
(2006-01-17 23:34) [#911]
Done.
RiffRaff:
((no subject))
(2006-01-13 18:55) [#891]
Is there some reason why the page of the month has to be created in the same month? I always just thought of it as highlighting good pages, whether they were created that month or not.
Unkx80:
Re: ((no subject))
(2006-01-13 20:27) [#895]
I thought so too. I don't think that Wikipedia's featured article has a same month requirement either.
MAsterdam:
Page of the month requirements (was "no subject")
(2006-01-13 21:26) [#899]
I'm not aware of any requirements.
The content of In A Korean Baduk School is dated.
It makes more sense to me as POTM september 2005 than januari 2006.
However, I feel that it was counternominated to Go in extreme places. By moving it this effect is gone.
So I'll wait a while - maybe somebody appreciates that effect so much he wants to make a case for it. I don't.
maruseru:
Re: Page of the month requirements (was "no subject")
(2006-01-15 10:48) [#908]
So there may only be one page to vote for each month? Sounds like a one-party communist election. :)
New reply
![[Welcome to Sensei's Library!]](images/stone-hello.png "Sensei's Library")