SirLyric: Why is it that when I make a major edit, giving it a useful comment, then notice a tiny mistake and make a minor edit, checking the box that says "don't log it to RecentChanges", the comment that shows on RecentChanges is the comment of the later, minor edit?
((moved from main page))
GoJaC: I agree that this behaviour is confusing/irritating. Any possibility of changing it to display the "major edit"'s message in RecentChanges? Or in what case does it make sense to keep the minor edit's message? It also seems to me that some minor edit history / diffs are actually lost (well, not kept), is this true? (I can't find a way to display the full minor-edit history of a page.) FullRecentChanges doesn't seem to show them either. (Maybe this happens when it's the same user making multiple sequential minor edits?)
My conclusions are that, when making a minor edit, one should keep the "Short summary of change" the same as the most recent major edit, pretend a minor edit is just a continuation of the most recent major edit. If this is indeed the case (in implementation, for example), then it does make sense to only show the most recent "summary of change" in RecentChanges, this behaviour should just be documented. I suppose this paragraph can serve as such documentation, but my feeling is it should be said a lot more tersely ;-), and these two paragraphs can then be deleted.
((moved from main page))
As GoJaC points out, there are several issues at work here:
I hope that clears things up a bit.