Forum for Kyu Exercise 84
Can this problem be posed differently? [#1605]
xela: Can this problem be posed differently?
(2008-11-02 00:41) [#5209]
It strikes me that this isn't a terribly interesting problem, since the "obvious" move (to pull out of atari) works, and since the contraint "black to save all stones" means that no other move can be considered.
Perhaps it would be better to ask the question: black to get the best endgame result (in which case pulling out of atari is wrong); or white to play after black pulls out of atari?
Unkx80: Problem recomposition
(2008-11-02 05:02) [#5211]
![[Diagram]](diagrams/31/fde59f9aab7ab58cb432761336a8356e.png)
It isn't terribly hard to recompose the problem so that saving all stones is the best solution.
Therefore, I suggest the following:
- Move the original composition to one of the endgame problem series, making pulling out from the atari the wrong answer.
- Replacing the original composition on this page with the modified composition.
Of course, I would appreciate if someone can check on the modified composition. =)
![[Welcome to Sensei's Library!]](images/stone-hello.png "Sensei's Library")