3354 Enclosure
This enclosure is common in pro play, to develop the 3-3 point (preventing the 3-3 point shoulderhit). If the 5-4 point is played first, it looks unambitious[1] to take the 3-3 point rather than make the small high shimari; and that development is rare in pro games.
White
here is the normal corner probe. Black
is the joseki answer most used in practice, but a and b are also seen. Note that this position also occurs in a typical 5-4 point tenuki joseki, by transposition.
Black
in answer is rare, but has been played by Ishida Yoshio (1982-11-25 against Iwata Tatsuaki). In that game Black had the marked stone in place. In general the exchange
-
looks like Black being forced (kikasare). This formation occurs also with the 3445 enclosure.
In contrast
here would only be played as a ko threat. Even then it is rare (one example in the Kajiwara-Kitani game in The Direction of Play). If Black answered at a that would be a local loss for White (i.e. the threat could be considered loss-making); in particular because the chance to play the probe discussed above is now gone.
Bill Spight suggests Black at b as alternate answer (since Black at a feels like kikasare).
It seems, though, that between strong players
will only be played when it is a ko threat that Black can't afford to answer; when White will cut through.
[1]
From a game Rui Naiwei-Hua Xueming in 1978. Black played
to secure the corner (rather than a) because White already occupied the 9-3 and 3-9 points.
![[Diagram]](../../diagrams/30/d3ba815cce587f467a5e838f49affe2a.png)
![[Diagram]](../../diagrams/31/836860ec6f6b6e91296ab69396f8d9f9.png)
![[Diagram]](../../diagrams/24/81f9277f25dde3b53bc265b307e0f112.png)
![[Diagram]](../../diagrams/49/842f0f236a7c41c18c4f48f71d068c93.png)
![[Diagram]](../../diagrams/31/c9aab2ca6b9c07286ba08deb0c74525e.png)
2024 the Authors,
published under the ![Sensei's Library [Welcome to Sensei's Library!]](../../images/stone-hello.png)