This is the consolidated version of all comments given during the review.
Game is completed. White won by resignation.
The SGF of the game is
here.
This composite review currently consists of comments by Kim Myungwan (who was asked by JoazBanbeck), Guo Juan (who was asked by tapir), our resident unkx80 one of the captains of the white team. kb is writing a complete and detailed review under Kb/WuRenGo2Review.
- Black does not have a move to play here. Losing territory. (Proposal: O4)
- Way too small, should be at R7.
- Too slow.
- D6 is better. Make use of move #9.
Proposal
- The top and right sides are miai. R8 looks good, as does K17. But either one allows white to play a 6-3 approach to the corner. So treat the sides as miai, and take O17 now.
: Black won't have enough territory.
: Too far especially when white is at d15 high position.
: P12 is best, prevents white O11.
: Thank you move! (Proposal: H17 or C12)
: O17 is best, threatens Q18.
: Very good.
: b14 is better.
: b15
: Overplay. (Proposal: J10)
was too deep. I prefer a reduction at around K8.
: (Proposal: J10 - better shape)
: b14 is still bigger, b8 second best.
(Proposal: M5 - I will go for the kill.)
feels unusually strong. I missed this move completely.
and
exchange is particularly loss making for white. White should have played
directly at
. If black played outside, then white can enter at N3. If black played at
, then white can choose to play at L9 or N9, much more efficient than at
.
- Very small. (Proposal: N9)
is unusually large, but at what price? For those who did not read it out, the real value of
is that it prevents white from entering at N3. With N3, white can either connect out or live unconditionally inside.
: Hane at 73, then extend.
is better played at
. I was too worried about the eyespace of the white group.