Handicap for smaller board sizes
(For the placement of handicap stones , see Handicap stone placement on smaller boards)
Table of contents |
Handicaps and komi for smaller boards
First possibility
Regarding handicap games, the following table gives one possible way of allocating handicap and komi on 13x13 boards. First column: Strength difference on 19x19 goban, second column, handicap on 13x13 goban, third column, komi to white.
Difference 13x13 Komi Difference 13x13 Komi 0 0 5.5 10 4 5.5
1(*) 0 5.5 11 4 2.5 2 0 2.5 12 4 0.5 3 0 0.5 13 5 5.5 4 2 5.5 14 5 2.5 5 2 2.5 15 5 0.5 6 2 0.5 16 6 5.5 7 3 5.5 17 6 2.5 8 3 2.5 18 6 0.5 9 3 0.5 19 6 -3.5
could someone please explain 6/-3.5 here? I'd rather say 7/5.5
xela: Some people (including myself) feel that putting more than six handicap stones on a 13x13 board (or for that matter, more than four on 9x9 or more than 9 on 19x19) gets a bit silly. Dieter: Quite so. People whose ranks differ 20 or more stones, are either unlikely to meet on the board at all or should not engage in a game beyond 9x9, unless for pure teaching purposes, in which case a correct handicap doesn't really matter.
(*) In the case of a one stone difference in strength, the weaker player takes black and plays first.
Second possibility (Tim Hunt)
On RGG, Tim Hunt posted his recommendations
Grade 13x13 board 9x9 board Difference Handicap Komi Handicap Komi 0 1 6 1 6
1 1 2 1 4 2 1 -2 1 2 3 2 4 1 0 4 2 0 1 -2 5 2 -4 1 -4
6 3 2 2 4 7 3 -2 2 2 8 4 4 2 0 9 4 0 2 -2 10 4 -4 2 -4
11 5 2 3 4 12 5 -2 3 2 13 6 4 3 0 14 6 0 3 -2 15 6 -4 3 -4
See also http://www.timhunt.me.uk/go/handicaps/
Third possibility (AGA)
There is a list of handicaps for small boards used by the American Go Association at AGA Handicaps.
Fourth possibility (RobertJasiek)
I have attended the small board tournaments at European Go Congresses since 1993 and watched many of the finals games. From that, I have observed that 8.5 komi for 13x13 and 6.5 komi for 9x9 (the latter is also currently used by Japanese professionals) frequently lead to strategically demanding 0.5 games. Whatever the handicap table is, these komi values are essential, unless one lets the players bid for the komi. Let me suggest some tables nevertheless, where handicap stones can be placed either freely or at the usual fixed patterns, which means 4x4 hoshis also on the 9x9. Free placement is significantly stronger in theory but still only very few players know to use that well.
Grade 13x13 board 9x9 board Difference Handicap Komi Handicap Komi 0 0 8.5 0 6.5 1 0 6.5 0 5.5 2 0 4.5 0 4.5 3 0 2.5 0 3.5 4 0 0.5 0 2.5 5 2 8.5 0 1.5 6 2 6.5 0 0.5 7 2 4.5 0 -0.5 8 2 2.5 0 -1.5 9 2 0.5 0 -2.5 10 3 8.5 2 6.5
etc.
Theoreticians notice that, according to the standard assumptions of the relation between komi and handicap, this is not linear. It works well for championship games in practice though. If Black does not know how to use his handicap (e.g., if he is an ordinary club player rather than well prepared for European championship level), then the system favours White.
axd: please refine "this is not linear": I assume "this" means the proposed table, and I see a linear relationship btn GD and K (and please remove my remark afterwards)
Cambridge club
The Cambridge club (see http://www.cam.ac.uk/societies/cugos/ for more details) uses a different system for its end-of-term 13x13 handicap competitions. These are played with fast time limits of 10 minutes each. In that case
2.5 grades = 1 handicap stone
Old Japanese Recommendation
Around 1985 there was an article in the Japanese magazine Igo Kurabu by Ishikura Noboru (now 9p) on komi and handicaps for both 9x9 and 13x13 boards. His recommendations were based on the results of many pro-pro games on these boards. Here is a table summarizing his recommendations:
Difference in strength 9x9 13x13 handi komi* handi komi*
0 1 5.5 1 5.5
1 1 3 1 0 2 1 0 1 -5 3 1 -3 2 5 4 1 -6 2 0 5 2 3 2 -5 6 2 0 3 5 7 2 -3 3 0 8 2 -6 3 -5 9 3 3 4 5 10 3 0 4 0 11 3 -3 4 -5 12 3 -6 5 5 13 4 3 5 0 14 4 0 5 -5 15 4 -3 6 5 16 4 -6 6 0 17 5 3 6 -5 18 5 0 7 5 19 5 -3 7 0 20 5 -6 7 -5 21 6 3 8 5 22 6 0 8 0 23 6 -3 8 -5 24 6 -6 9 5 25 7 3 9 0 26 7 0 9 -5 27 7 -3 10 5 28 7 -6 10 0 29 8 3 10 -5 30 8 0 11 5
*komi given by Black, so negative number means reverse komi.
Rule-of-thumb
- Jeff: At the start of a 13x13 with someone, I hand them 6 prisoners (komi) plus 4 per rank difference. I then let them use ten stones to buy one handicap stone. I let them do this as many times as they want until their number of prisoners becomes negative. Similarly with 9x9: 6 prisoners plus 2/rank
(axd) This corresponds to
size start diff H-price 13 6 4 10 9 6 2 10?
Where:
start = number of W prisoners given to B diff = additional number of W prisoners for each rank difference H-price = number of W prisoners to return for each handicap
axd: todo: sizes 5,7,19
Switching over to larger sizes
It can be handy to have an idea when to switch from a smaller board to a larger board when playing against (much) weaker players. This allows to present an attractive learning path for beginners, that might otherwise stick too long to a small board size or switch too soon to larger sizes when playing against stronger players.
Maximum handicaps
An option is to switch to the larger size once the strength difference equals the maximum number of handicaps that are usually given on the larger size
from H to H rank diff ------- -- ------- -- ---------- 9x9 3 13x13 6 approx. 14 13x13 4 19x19 9 9
Notes
- from 13 to 19 would be at 5H according to AGA Handicaps, 4 according to Tim Hunt table, 3 according to 'First Possibility' table.
- to add: 5x5 and 7x7 boards
Maximum komi (less usual)
Rather than play with handicaps, as handicaps and komi are in relationship with each other, whenever Black manages to win without handicaps but with a specific (negative) komi, (s)he is "promoted" to a larger size board.
By lack of a better rule-of-thumb, following values are solely based on linear extrapolations (proportional to area) from 9H=140K on 19x19 - anyone with a better idea, feel free to improve.
from K to ------ ---- ------ 5x5 9? 7x7 7x7 19? 9x9 9x9 31? 13x13 13x13 65? 19x19
(to develop)
see also forum:komi
Links
- Rank And Handicap/Discussion: the smaller the board, the more subjective handicap stones become?
-
http://jakobsen.dyndns.dk/edo/pages_english/handicaptables.htm
-
http://gobond.nl/Generiek/ToonPagina.php?Pagina=15 (in case the link changes: go Home -> Informatie -> Voorgift Tabel )