Kee Rules Of Go/ Feedback

Sub-page of KeeRulesOfGo

Robert Pauli: Dear Wilton, some humble suggestions and stupid questions :--)

  1. not adjacent to any intersection in the same status: Actually the closeness of a non-singleton group is missing too.
  2. if an intersection of the former is adjacent to that of the latter: Since order is of no matter, if an intersection of one is adjacent to that of the other might be better.
  3. emtpy group: Since this sounds like empty set, uncolored group or unoccupied group might be better.
  4. An area of a player is the union of her territories and groups adjacent to each other.: Why adjacent to each other? Couldn't that be dropped?
  5. A declared area is an area formed by capturing groups of all players declared dead.: Don't get it.
    • Area with no alive stones?
    • What's a capturing group?
  6. anticipated area: Is that an area with no own alive stones?
  7. two players playing with black and white stones: Better two players, one playing with black, the other with white stones or has two colors, black and white. Players play with a unique color.
  8. cannot place a stone to produce a captive group in her color: At the very moment of placement this very well is allowed, so maybe add . . . if no opposing groups become captive.
  9. all captive opponent groups are captured from: Better . . . are removed from.
  10. cannot place a stone to produce: Maybe better may not place . . .
  11. A player has to declare which of her groups are dead . . .:
    • Why the heck should she declare any stone of herself dead at all??
    • She herself passed for the first time in that position or nobody but she did?
  12. A player can anticipate . . .: Why shouldn't she boldly declare all opposing stones dead??
  13. to produce a board position ever passed by any player: Maybe to produce a board position at least one player already has passed in.
  14. A player can use her anticipated area to replace her declared area with release of all groups captured in the declared area after anticipation, if all intersections in the anticipated area also belong to the declared area.
    Not even I get it :--))
  15. ranked higher: Ranking is one's performance over many games. Maybe A player has won if each other player has less points might be better.
  16. Hint: Once I praised my rules on Rules of Go -- those with this and that -- but I purged that again . . .

This is a copy of the living page "Kee Rules Of Go/ Feedback" at Sensei's Library.
(OC) 2004 the Authors, published under the OpenContent License V1.0.
[Welcome to Sensei's Library!]
StartingPoints
ReferenceSection
About