BQM 61

Path: BigQuestionMark   · Prev: BQM60   · Next: BQM62
    Keywords: Life & Death, Question

I received the following question about the carpenter's square and forward it to SL while I'm thinking about it myself.

[Diagram]

Carpenter's square

White 1 is said to be incorrect because it allows Black to live in seki.

[Diagram]

The basic position

After this position two variations arise: a and b.

[Diagram]

Seki

After 2, Black's seven-space big eye space is of living kind. White can't make an eye in it, and neither can she almost fill with a killing shape. So far so good.

[Diagram]

Life (?)

The second variation as given in the book of my correspondent is this one.

[Diagram]

Life (?)

Now, Black throws in and then the book says something like White must connect at a and Black captures at b: White can't play c because of shortage of liberties. So Black lives. However, ...

[Diagram]

Death !

White simply captures a stone, letting Black cut her stones. Next, she fills a Black liberty. Black is dead.


Dieter

... But I think I found it already.

[Diagram]

Life !

Yes. This is a position that is often given as a life-and-death problem, and 1 is the correct answer. --Tim Hunt


[Diagram]

Seki

How does it work if I put 3 in there? Looks like a killing shape to me. munchkin

unkx80: Still a seki, Black plays elsewhere.


Path: BigQuestionMark   · Prev: BQM60   · Next: BQM62
This is a copy of the living page "BQM 61" at Sensei's Library.
(OC) 2004 the Authors, published under the OpenContent License V1.0.
[Welcome to Sensei's Library!]
StartingPoints
ReferenceSection
About