GokyoShumyoSection5Problem24/Attempts

[Diagram]

solution

[Diagram]

failure

xela: If black plays at B1 first, then after W2, white wins the race.

joelr: Shouldn't W4 be at a, else Black gets out to b? And what about

[Diagram]

alternate


To me, this solution seems incomplete. Black moving to 3 is a mistake; White can make an eye forcing Black into an unfavourable situation. A KO can develop. We shall assume that KO for Black is bad.

[Diagram]

Refuting the "solution"

[Diagram]

Assuming KO is bad for Black, Black joins...

[Diagram]

Liberty fight looks bad for Black now. (I couldn't find another way for Black to fight and gain liberties)


This order of moves is better for Black

[Diagram]

REAL(?) solution

[Diagram]

REAL(?) solution

This fight seems alot harder for White to win.

tapir: Black is dead after the last white move (I added it). White just has to give him the three stones on the left.


This is a copy of the living page "GokyoShumyoSection5Problem24/Attempts" at Sensei's Library.
(OC) 2014 the Authors, published under the OpenContent License V1.0.
[Welcome to Sensei's Library!]
StartingPoints
ReferenceSection
About