Direction Of Play/ Discussion

Sub-page of DirectionOfPlay

Direction of Play left undefined?

Rich: I think the book makes it quite clear early on that all stones have power, and that this extends in one or more directions, depending on position and neighbouring stones. The direction of play is therefore the direction that makes best use of the power of stones already played. This may be too difficult or vague to grasp in many cases, but IMO it is defined.

Charles Unfortunately the 'power' concept in go is even less clear than influence, thickness - which cause us enough trouble here. Then K postulates that it is a 'vector' quantity. Then you have to optimize it, somehow, relative to existing stones ...

No, this is trying to define how you play go well, not give you a working concept. There are two attitudes I have found useful in dealing with the points the book raises:

  • there is something here you have to learn to become strong, namely it is no good trying to play go well unless you want to become rigorous about working your stones to close to 100%;

and

  • what you therefore do is to try to maximise some sort of coherence function, replacing the evaluation function idea that applies well to chess computing.

When you understand the first point it becomes much clearer why go improvement becomes harder at dan level - you can get less from good local pattern-matching. And the second point explains something (to me at least) about why good moves can look so odd (as one sees in Kajiwara's games).

By the way, I have probably brought this up before, but Cho Hun-hyeon is on the record as finding K's theories opaque. So in a sense I am contesting this on behalf of haengma, a rival concept, on which Cho is an acknowledged master.

Bill: Kajiwara is a good read, and stimulates thought. But he should not be taken as gospel.


This is a copy of the living page "Direction Of Play/ Discussion" at Sensei's Library.
(OC) 2005 the Authors, published under the OpenContent License V1.0.
[Welcome to Sensei's Library!]
StartingPoints
ReferenceSection
About