Calvin: This page looks like a bad idea. At best, it will look like SL is endorsing a particular server. At worst, it will degenerate into a flame war.
jfc: ditto. The risks of this page out weigh the benefits. It is enough to simply provide information about how to access the two servers and then let people decide for themselves.
YouCantWin: I hope that won't happen-_-. But letting people argue is fine.