![]() StartingPoints Paths Referenced by
|
The Keima Shimari Is Secure
Keywords: Shape, Tactics
We all know the shimari on 3-4 and 5-3 securely encloses the corner. If Black invades, he can't live, can he? HolIgor: The general statement is that the invader can't live, but the defender kills with so much strain, leaving such cutting points in the wall that the outside influence changes this statement. For one, I like to invade keima shimari. And playing white in the position in the next diagram I'd like add one more stone to defend the corner.
Late in the midgame, the corner looked something like this. White's corner shimari was loosely surrounded by my living Black group. I decided to invade the shimari. If I could even force a seki there, it would be a gain for me; and since a play there was sente, I had nothing to lose (as long as White's responses didn't decrease my territory). Plus, I thought my nearby stones would help the invasion. White's answers allowed me to build a small living group, which in turn meant the White stones lacked eyes and were dead. Our later analysis revealed that White had a line of play that would have kept the corner. But the more I play around with it, the more it looks like an invasion on the 3-2 point can force a ko.
After White 10, I played at a. This is silly, because White can kill with b. (If Black c, then White d ensures there's only one eye.) But if Black takes b, White has to play e. Then Black plays a, and White must capture the ko.
If Black has the better and more numerous ko threats, Black will either get the corner or get compensation elsewhere.
This is a success for Black -- the Black stones have connected out to live, and White must still scramble to live. (In fact, Black at a seems to kill; and it's Black's turn...) White's two defenses against the invasion at 3-2 seem to yield either a large loss of territory, or a large ko fight. So I conclude: "the keima shimari is secure" is a controversial statement. Clearly, if the shimari becomes loosely surrounded, White needs an extra move to avoid complication.
Comments? Does White have a better line of play?
BillSpight: Controversial? It's just wrong. :-)
W 4 looks better than 7. Later, B 9 can make ko.
B 1 is the usual attack, I think. :-) If Black can't stand the ko, he can play at 9 instead of 7.
W 1 is often the killer tesuji. However,
B 4 fills at 1.
TakeNGive: Having looked at this some more, I wonder if there's a better defense of the shimari against a 3-2 attack -- more comments, please?
Black will need 3 or 4 unanswered moves to live, it seems; not going to happen.
Does Black have something I'm overlooking? - TakeNGive See the continuation below. B is just too strong on the outside I think. DaveSigaty
This is a copy of the living page "The Keima Shimari Is Secure" at Sensei's Library. (C) the Authors, published under the OpenContent License V1.0. |