![]() StartingPoints Paths Referenced by Homepages
|
Sow Discord In The Enemies Camp
Difficulty: Beginner
Keywords: Proverb, Tactics, Strategy
Here's what I take from this: Since you are desperate (and you are probably losing), it can't hurt to invade a base that has not yet established 2 eyes. Your opponent might have to respond (you gain sente) and he might mess up, allowing you to destroy his group. If played right, you lose no points because for every piece you play in his camp, he has to respond with a piece of his own. So you lose one stone and he loses a space on the board. Note: This is probably not very elegant. But you are desperate
Here is an example: The Comb Formation is alive. However, if White were desperate, she could play at a or b. This requires Black to respond to keep the group alive. So the net point exchange is 0; but Black may commit a fatal error (White hopes) and not protect the group, in which case White has won the group. -- SifuEric unkx80: You have a point, but from a pratical point of view, such moves wastes ko threats. Also, if this is overdone, then I don't think that it is nice etiquette. If you think that you are really losing and have no chance of winning, perhaps you should just resign? SifuEric: I think you are absolutely right. I was just trying to give my interpretation of the strategy. Especially if you have no chance of winning, resign. You will keep your dignity and people will still play you. I would only use this strategy if winning that particular game were extremely important (and etiquette not quite as important). Never in a friendly game. Gorobei: The main problem of applying war proverbs to Go is that they often just don't apply. Much of the writing of Sun Tzu, Machiavelli, and the author(s) of the 36 strategems is concerned with explaining how war is more than just massed troops fighting to the death on a muddy field. Many strategems, if applied to Go, would be considered bad sportsmanship (or "gamesmanship" for them that have read Stephen Potter or watched Bobby Riggs) E.g...
TakeNGive 10k: Who is the enemy? Where is the camp? Andre Engels 3D: If I were to choose an interpretation of this in Go terms, I would first look at the preparation of invasions: Start with some easily discarded kikashi, which only serve to 'sow discord', before you throw in the important invasion stones. Another thing would indeed be probing moves: By making the opponent play first, you are making his stones stand on the wrong places. More generally, one could apply this proverb to any tactic that makes the opponent's stones have incorrect shape for the occasion. This is a copy of the living page "Sow Discord In The Enemies Camp" at Sensei's Library. (C) the Authors, published under the OpenContent License V1.0. |