RGG FAQ Part 4 Section 6

Path: <= RGG FAQ =>
    Keywords: Question

This page is part of the rec.games.go FAQ on SL, and cannot be edited directly. A copy of this page can be edited by following the link at the bottom of this page, but please read the FAQ Format Guidelines first.

For more details on the workings of the FAQ, see rec.games.go FAQ on SL.

4.6: Posting positions to the Newsgroup

The newsgroup is an excellent place to post questions regarding positions that have come up in play, or problems seen in books.

It sometimes makes sense to include a diagram showing the local position, with stones, as well as the sequence of moves played / variations etc.

Following these guidelines will make sure readers understand what you are trying to show:

  • Do not use HTML or other formatting. The use of pure ascii makes sure that the diagrams do not become distorted. For the same reason, do not use <tab>s, but only spaces.
  • Always edit (and read) news posts using a fixedwidth font, such as Courier. With a variablewidth font, others will see the post different from you, which means diagrams and other "ASCII pictures" will not line up properly. Using a fixedwidth font ensures others see the message as you intended it.
  • A White stone is given as O (capital o), a black stone is given as # or X.
  • The goban is represented by a set of dots/periods (.), one for each intersection. The lines on the grid itself are not shown.
  • For clarity, it is useful to mark the hoshi (star) points, with commas (,) or plusses (+) (according to personal taste)
  • Make sure it is obvious where the edge is (if relevant). Either make a mention of it ('bottom left corner') or draw the board edges on the diagram using |, - and +.
  • Use spaces between characters.
  • Sequences of moves are shown with numbers 1,2 etc. Make sure you state whether 1 is black or white
  • Because of this, it is not advisable to show more than 9 moves on one diagram. If you want to show more, you should use more diagrams, each one giving the 'end position' of the last one as 'start position' of the new one.
  • Variations are shown with letters. 'a', 'b', etc.
  • If it is relevant, make sure you state how many prisoners have been taken. Since 'white:3, black:13' is easily misunderstood, write it out: 'white has taken 3 prisoners, black 13.'
  • Most people will read the posts on a screen, and it can be awkward to scroll back up to see the diagram when reading the discussion below. Try not to have the text too far away from the diagram.
  • Include a description of those aspects of the position you want to discuss/ask about.

An example:

 . . . . . . .|
 . . O . . . .|
 . # O + O . .|
 . . # # O . .|
 . . . . . . .|
 . . . . . . .|

On his web site, Jan VAN DER STEEN has [ext] a tool which will translate an SGF file to ascii diagrams.

Back to Section top

Back to top

Path: <= RGG FAQ =>
RGG FAQ Part 4 Section 6 last edited by tapir on August 9, 2013 - 12:05
RecentChanges · StartingPoints · About
Search · Related · Page info · Latest diff
[Welcome to Sensei's Library!]
Search position
Page history
Latest page diff
Partner sites:
Go Teaching Ladder
Login / Prefs
Sensei's Library